Best Used Trucks on the Market in 2023

Pickup trucks are a popular choice for many due to their utility and versatility, and automakers have been quick to respond with various models to meet the different needs of consumers. While this is certainly a plus, it can make purchasing a used truck more challenging due to the wide range of options available. To help simplify the process, we at Performance Kings Honda have compiled this list of some of the best used trucks you can find on the market today. Read on to find out the best years for each model in the list.

Honda Ridgeline (2010 and 2020)

Honda Ridgeline RTL 2020 by RLGNZLZ is licensed with CC BY-SA 2.0

The Honda Ridgeline is known for blending utility and comfort, and it’s a popular alternative to traditional trucks that focus on hauling and towing. While it isn’t as powerful, it’s still a capable pickup that can handle various tasks. And although it’s smaller than most other trucks, it offers a comfortable ride and a good amount of interior space, which makes it a great choice, even for families.

Many Ridgeline model years stand out for their reliability and overall value. The 2010, 2012, 2017, 2019, and 2020 Ridgeline have made it to the lists of the best used trucks at different price points by U.S. News & World Report. Kelley Blue Book named the 2013 model as one of the best options for a midsize truck under $20,000, and MotorBiscuit recognized 2011 and 2020 as the best years for this Honda truck.

Which used Honda Ridgeline is the best will depend primarily on your budget and needs. If you’re looking for an affordable compact truck, your most practical choice may be the 2010 Ridgeline. If you want a more modern pickup with a roomy interior and high fuel economy for its class, go with the 2020 model. Get in touch with us for more information about the Honda Ridgeline and to get help determining which one is right for you.

Ford F-150 (2009 and 2017)

The F-150 has been a popular choice for decades due to its reliability and performance. Many model years are great options, but your choice will ultimately depend on your priorities. If affordability is important, opt for the 2009 F-150. It’s in U.S. News’ top five for best used full-size trucks under $25,000, and it’s also considered one of the best picks by KBB if you’re looking for a truck with a budget of less than $8,000.

The 2017 is also a good choice. The car app Jerry recommends it if you want updated features, such as Apple CarPlay and Android Auto integration, and a 10-speed automatic transmission that’s not offered on older models. MotorBiscuit also cites the towing and hauling capabilities of both model years as an advantage. Properly equipped, the 2009 and 2017 F-150 can tow a maximum of 11,300 and 13,200 lbs, which are both impressive figures.

Chevrolet Colorado (2015 and 2016)

The Colorado started as a compact truck but has since been redesigned as a midsize model. The 2016 model is part of its third and latest generation, and both U.S. News and MotorBiscuit recognize it as among the best used trucks in 2023. The 2016 Chevrolet Colorado stands out because it features an optional diesel engine that delivers more torque than the standard gasoline-powered engine.

If you aren’t interested in the diesel engine, you can choose the 2015 Colorado. This model is Motor Trend’s Truck of the Year for 2015 because while it’s more affordable than full-size trucks, it doesn’t sacrifice performance or style. It’s also included in Kelley Blue Book’s list of the best used midsize trucks under $20,000.

GMC Sierra 1500 (2012 and 2020)

GMC vehicles are known for their quality and durability, and the 2012 Sierra 1500 is no exception. It’s recognized by Jerry as one of the best used GMC Sierra trucks, and it placed fourth in U.S. News’ list of the best used full-size trucks that cost less than $25,000. While its exterior and technology may be outdated compared with newer models, it still offers comfortable and stylish interiors and impressive payload capacity. It’s a sensible choice if you want an affordable vehicle that still performs well.

For a more recent model, the 2020 Sierra 1500 is a solid choice. It’s the highest-ranked large light-duty truck in the 2023 U.S. Vehicle Dependability Study by J.D. Power, which looked at how dependable different 2020 vehicles are after three years of ownership. There have also been fewer issues for this model year compared with its predecessors, according to CarComplaints.com.

Toyota Tacoma (2013 and 2018)

Those in the market for a used midsize truck often have the Tacoma on their list. It’s popular due to its off-road capabilities and reputation for durability. The 2013 and 2015 model years both placed fourth in U.S. News’ list of the best used compact trucks under $20,000, while the 2016 and 2018 came in second place for best pickups that are priced higher.

Among these, the 2013 Tacoma may be the most attractive option in terms of price. It’s also a reliable truck, with an 86 out of 100 score from J.D. Power. If you want something newer, the 2018 Tacoma is a good choice. It’s a third-generation model that’s significantly more reliable than its predecessors, which are plagued with various issues. It may also be less expensive than more recent models.

This list isn’t exhaustive, and there are other models also worth considering, such as the Chevrolet Colorado, Ram 1500, and Nissan Frontier. When shopping for a pre-owned truck, it’s important to consider your needs, preferences, and financial standing. It’s also crucial to do your research and look into a vehicle’s history before you make a purchase.

You can start your search by going through our inventory of used vehicles, all of which we have inspected to ensure they’re in good condition. You can also contact or visit us in Cincinnati, Ohio, to find out more about the pre-owned trucks we have for sale.